Raw spread vs standard account calculator
The difference is only as good as the spreads you type. A live spread moves.
The two shapes
A standard account folds the venue’s cost into the spread. A raw or ECN-style account shows a tighter spread and then a commission per lot. Which one is cheaper depends on how many lots you trade and how wide each spread actually is. At one lot a month the commission can dominate. At a hundred lots the tighter spread usually wins, if the raw spread you typed is real.
This is not a ranking of IC Markets, Pepperstone, Exness or anyone else. Those names show up in affiliate pitches because the payouts are large. The arithmetic does not care. Residents of India do not get a CFD button from this page.
See also the swap calculator if you hold overnight. Spread is the entry. Swap is the night.
A partner link appears here only where that firm accepts customers from your region. The numbers above never depend on it.
How to use this calculator
- Enter the lots you trade in a month and the pip value per lot.
- Type the standard account spread in pips, as you see it on your tickets at the times you trade.
- Type the raw account spread and its commission per lot for a round turn.
- Read the difference. Positive means the standard account costs more on your numbers.
Worked example
With 20 lots a month and a pip value of 10: a 1.4-pip standard spread costs 20 × 10 × 1.4 = 280. A raw account at 0.1 pips plus 7 per lot costs 20 × (1 + 7) = 160. The raw account saves 120 a month here. At 2 lots a month the saving is only 12, and a minimum deposit or platform fee may cancel it.
- Standard, 280. 20 lots × 10 × 1.4 pips. The whole cost is inside the spread.
- Raw, 160. 20 × (0.1 pip × 10 + 7 commission) = 20 × 8.
- Standard at 2 lots, 28. Same maths, a tenth of the volume.
- Raw at 2 lots, 16. Still cheaper per lot, but the 12 saved a month is easy to lose elsewhere.
On the real screen: Type your own lots, spread and commission above; the tool shows the same four numbers.
Good habitCompare the spread at the hours you actually trade, not the advertised minimum.
Common mistakeComparing a raw spread with a standard spread and forgetting the commission.
If your broker quotes per million or in basis points
This calculator takes commission per lot. For per-million or basis-point pricing, or to see the cost in pips on yen and other cross pairs, use the FX commission calculator. It shows, for example, that a $7 round trip is 0.70 pips on EUR/USD but about 1.05 pips on USD/JPY at 150.
Common questions
Is a raw spread account always cheaper?
Not always. It wins when you trade enough lots for the narrower spread to outweigh the commission. The break-even is the commission divided by the spread difference in money.
Why does my spread differ from the advertised one?
Advertised spreads are often averages or minimums in liquid hours. Spreads widen around news, at the daily rollover and in thin markets.
Eight lots on two account shapes
The inputs are 8 lots in a month, a pip value of 10, a standard spread of 1.2 pips, a raw spread of 0.2 pips, and a raw commission of 6 per lot round turn. These are typed figures, not a firm's live price.
The standard month is 8 × 1.2 × 10 = 96.00. There is no commission in that line. The raw month is 8 × 0.2 × 10 + 8 × 6 = 16.00 + 48.00 = 64.00. The difference is 96.00 - 64.00 = 32.00. On these inputs the standard spread costs more.
A raw account is not always cheaper. If the raw spread widens, or the lot count is tiny, the commission can cost more than the tighter spread saves. Hold the 8 lots and the commission of 6, and set the raw spread to 1.0 pip as a changed input. Raw cost becomes 8 × 1.0 × 10 + 48.00 = 80.00 + 48.00 = 128.00. That is 32.00 above the standard month of 96.00. The 1.0 pip case is not the example. It only shows the flip. The example remains 96.00 against 64.00.
How the month cost is built
Formula. Standard month = lots × standard spread in pips × pip value. Raw month = lots × raw spread in pips × pip value + lots × commission per lot round turn. Difference = standard month - raw month. A positive difference means the standard shape costs more on those inputs. Here, 8 × 1.2 × 10 = 96.00, and 8 × 0.2 × 10 + 8 × 6 = 64.00, so the difference is 32.00.
The raw spread that matches the standard month solves 8 × S × 10 + 48.00 = 96.00. Then 80 × S = 48.00, so S = 0.60 pips. Wider than 0.60 pips, the raw month costs more than 96.00 at these 8 lots. Tighter than 0.60, it costs less. The typed 0.2 sits below that line, which is why 64.00 is below 96.00.
Round turn means the commission of 6 covers the entry and the exit of one lot in this sketch. It is not 6 to open and another 6 to close, unless your schedule says the 6 was one way. Read the schedule. Eight lots then cost 48.00, not 6.00.
When the raw side costs more
| Shape | Spread cash | Commission | Month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard, 1.2 pips | 96.00 | None in this sketch | 96.00 |
| Raw, 0.2 pips | 16.00 | 48.00 | 64.00 |
| Raw, if the spread were 1.0 | 80.00 | 48.00 | 128.00 |
| Crossover raw spread | Depends on S | 48.00 | Equals 96.00 at 0.60 pips |
The third row is a changed input, not a quote. Spreads move during the day. The number on an advertisement can be quieter than the number on your ticket. Type the spread you were filled at. An overnight financing charge is not inside 96.00 or 64.00. Add it from the dealer's schedule if you hold past the roll, or the month is incomplete.
Mistakes with pip costs
- Calling a raw account cheaper on every ticket. At a wide raw spread the commission can win the comparison the other way.
- Using 1.2 pips when the ticket was wider. The month then understates the standard side.
- Charging 6 once for 8 lots. The sketch charges 6 per lot, so commission is 48.00.
- Treating 6 as one way when the schedule means one way, or the reverse. Round turn has to match the words on the fee page.
- Comparing this sketch with an Indian currency-futures contract note. Those costs are not a forex-swap account.
This page does not link an offshore forex or CFD firm. Residents of India are not being pointed at one. Currency futures on a recognised Indian exchange are a different product, in permitted pairs only. Their costs are brokerage, securities transaction tax, GST and the bid-ask, not the 1.2 versus 0.2 pip account above. Use the forex calculator for pip arithmetic, the cost note for how spread, commission and swap sit apart, and the commission calculator when the charge is a ticket fee rather than a pip.
Other rulebooks, and four checks
In the United States, retail forex sits under the CFTC. This page does not copy a firm's spread. In the UK and the EU, the FCA and ESMA publish the current product rules. Do not reuse a leverage figure from memory. Australia, the UAE and Singapore license dealers locally. None of that text changes 8 × 1.2 × 10. It can change whether the account exists for you.
What does round turn mean for the commission of 6?
Here it is 6 for the entry and the exit of one lot together. Eight lots cost 48.00. If the schedule bills 6 per side, the raw month is higher than 64.00. Retype the commission.
Why is the gap 32.00 only for these inputs?
Because 96.00 - 64.00 uses 8 lots, pip value 10, spreads of 1.2 and 0.2, and commission of 6. At a raw spread of 0.60 pips the two months meet. Wider than that, on these lots, the raw side costs more.
Does an overnight charge sit inside the 96.00?
No. The 96.00 is spread only. The 64.00 is spread plus round-turn commission. Financing for nights you hold is extra. A debit can erase the 32.00 gap.
How should a reader in India use this page?
As arithmetic on typed pips, not as a path to an offshore forex or CFD account. Exchange-traded currency derivatives use brokerage, STT, GST and their own spread, in permitted pairs on a recognised Indian exchange. Do not paste 64.00 into that contract note.
Sources
- U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission — US framework for retail forex, separate from a typed pip sketch (checked 10 November 2026).
- Financial Conduct Authority — UK rules for firms that offer CFD-style accounts (checked 10 November 2026).
- ESMA — EU product-intervention material on CFDs (checked 10 November 2026).
- NSE India — currency derivatives on a recognised Indian exchange, a different product from this pip sketch (checked 10 November 2026).
- SEBI — Indian market rules for exchange-traded currency derivatives (checked 10 November 2026).
